top of page

What Is Immediacy in Counselling?

Writer: Ben Jackson
Ben Jackson
5 hours ago
5 min read

Immediacy in counselling means noticing what is happening between you and your client in the moment, and bringing it into the room. You offer it as an observation, not a statement of fact, and without judgement. Done well, immediacy moves the conversation away from the surface and towards what sits underneath it.


Something sent, something received


Every exchange carries more than the words. Something is sent and something is received, often at a level neither person notices. Immediacy is the skill of tuning into those undertones and naming them.


The work starts with you. A client says something and you feel a flicker of shame, or irritation, or a pull to reassure. Rather than acting on the feeling or pushing it away, you treat it as information.


A recent client of mine made several comments about how my therapy room was laid out. They didn't need to be complimentary, but they had a sharpness to them, a tinge of criticism. Ignoring them would have lost an opportunity to explore.


So I said something like: "I heard you comment on how this room is laid out. It didn't need to be complimentary, but there seemed to be some sharpness to it. I wonder if you noticed that."


The conversation shifted from something on the surface to something underneath it. Immediacy sits close to how you challenge a client, and it asks the same of you: an invitation, not a verdict.


What a handshake tells you


You meet someone for the first time and they hold out their hand. There is a message inside the gesture, and you answer it without thinking.


What happens if you don't take the hand straight away, and name what you see instead? "I notice you want to shake hands. What's behind that for you?" Some people will call it politeness. Often there is more inside the gesture than manners: a need for reassurance, for some security in an unfamiliar place.


An uninvited criticism of the room carries a message too. Immediacy brings these automatic exchanges to the surface and asks: is this something you recognise?


Is the feeling yours or theirs?


Every trainee asks this, and it's why counselling training takes three to four years. Training and your own personal therapy are where you learn how much of a reaction belongs to you and how much comes from the client.


You won't always know, and the aim isn't certainty. The aim is to stay unreactive, observe what's happening, and bring it in when it feels appropriate.


Say a client's comment stirs up shame in you. You get curious. Is there anything here for me to feel ashamed of? If not, where is the feeling coming from? If the comment is spiky towards you, perhaps it lands that way with other people in the client's life too.


You offer it tentatively, and you own your part: "I notice something in me responding to what you said, a sense of being criticised, and it's touching on some inadequacy in me. Does that resonate with you at all?"


The client is free to dismiss it. So much of what passes between people is automatic and outside awareness. Your job is to bring it to the surface, not to be right about it.


Where students go wrong


Immediacy sits more comfortably at Level 3 and above than at Level 2, where students are still working themselves out. When it goes wrong in skills practice, the student has usually used it too quickly, without enough understanding behind it.


What doesn't land is a student justifying their own feeling and forcing their peer to engage with it. The tone turns defensive or judgemental rather than curious, and the student mistakes their reaction for a fact about the other person.


The better stance is curiosity, generosity and respect. The person in front of you is giving you a window on how they experience life. Their way of being is feedback.


When immediacy misfires, the cause is nearly always unexamined material in the counsellor, who hasn't worked through what the moment evokes in them.


When the relationship is ready


There is no timeline. The question is whether the relationship feels able to hold the observation gently. Rapport is your first guide, along with how the relationship has developed and where the conversation is heading.


Sometimes holding back is the right call, if your observation would pull the focus away from what the client came to say.


Watch your own resistance too. We rarely pin a feeling down between two people and say, "I'm noticing a tension here, and I'd like to explore it with you." Most of us are never invited into that conversation, so it feels awkward. If the same thing keeps coming up and you keep deflecting from it, ask why. There might be material there for both of you.


That's what supervision is for. I use mine to look at the moments I didn't bring into the room, and at the layers of me getting in the way.


If the idea frightens you


Of course it does. Naming what is happening between two people goes against most of what we learn about being polite.


Being frightened is a starting point, not a problem. Ask what frightens you about it. There is a personal story inside the fear, and it's worth getting closer to.


Training gives you a place to practise. In the personal development group, the invitation is to explore whatever surfaces between members, not as blame but as a difficult experience held with some safety. By Level 4, the encouragement is to bring courage into that space: to stay in the discomfort and work through it. The aim isn't to replay old relationships but to understand yourself better.


Every time you meet the thing you avoid, ask about it. What you learn there is what you bring to your clients.


Frequently Asked Questions


What is an example of immediacy in counselling?


A client makes a sharp comment about how the therapy room is laid out. The counsellor says, "I heard you comment on how this room is laid out, and there seemed to be some sharpness to it. I wonder if you noticed that." The observation invites the client to look at what sits underneath the comment.


When should a counsellor use immediacy?


There is no set point. Use it when the rapport feels strong enough to hold the observation gently, and when it won't pull focus from what the client came to share. If you keep noticing something and avoiding it, take it to supervision.


Why do counselling students find immediacy difficult?


Naming what is happening between two people goes against everyday habits, so it feels awkward and often frightening. Students also tend to use it too early, before they have worked through what the moment stirs up in them.


At The School of Counselling, we deliver CPCAB-accredited Level 2 and Level 3 counselling training online via Zoom, and a Level 4 Diploma in Therapeutic Counselling in person at monthly weekend intensives with monthly online lessons. Our courses are built around personal development groups and supervision, where you practise this kind of noticing. Find out more at schoolofcounselling.com.


Want more from the school? Letters from the school, our newsletter, arrives monthly or quarterly, your choice, with one main article, course dates and events. Sign up here.

 
 
bottom of page